Menu of 5 Brothers Chicken & Waffles in Setauket- East Setauket, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Located in Setauket-East Setauket, NY, 5 Brothers Chicken & Waffles is a vibrant eatery that champions classic comfort food with a modern twist. Specializing in the beloved Southern duo of fried chicken and waffles, this restaurant delivers generous portions and authentic flavors that leave a lasting impression.

The heart of the menu lies in its perfectly seasoned, juicy fried chicken paired with fluffy, golden waffles. Portions are sizeable, offering everything from a hearty 3-piece chicken & waffle combo to large trays suitable for gatherings — like the 75-piece chicken with a full tray of waffles and sides at $349.99, which highlights their commitment to generous, shareable meals. The chicken itself is often praised for its meaty tenderness and depth of flavor, which shines through whether you choose tenders, mixed cuts, or whole wings.

Beyond chicken and waffles, the menu showcases a delightful array of sides and unique treats that elevate the dining experience. Favorites include their crunchy Buffalo Wings and Fries, crispy Sweet Corn Nuggets, and golden Onion Rings, all crafted to complement the main dishes perfectly. The Bubble Waffle Cone Ice Cream offers a playful finish — combining a light, airy waffle with creamy ice cream, making for a memorable dessert that stands out from typical fare.

Desserts like Homemade Banana Pudding and Pecan Pie bring a comforting, nostalgic quality to the meal, resonating well with those who crave authentic Southern-style sweets. The Red Velvet Cake is another popular pick, though some diners suggest being mindful of sweetness levels. For those who appreciate seafood, the menu also features generous baskets of Jumbo Shrimp fried to a golden crisp, providing a satisfying alternative to the traditional hearty chicken offerings.

Customers repeatedly note the freshness and quality of the food along with the friendly atmosphere. Reviewers highlight the value for money, the robust seasoning on the chicken, and the fluffiness of the waffles. While some suggest ordering ahead due to preparation time, it seems the wait is well rewarded. A minor drawback shared by regulars is the absence of soft drink options directly in the restaurant, requiring a quick trip to the convenient store next door, but this does little to diminish the overall positive experience.

Overall, 5 Brothers Chicken & Waffles encapsulates the spirit of comfort food done right. With a menu that balances generous portions, bold flavors, and a touch of creativity—especially seen in their waffle-based desserts and sides—this spot is ideal for anyone seeking hearty, soulful meals. Whether you’re craving classic fried chicken, inventive waffle combos, or homestyle Southern desserts, 5 Brothers delivers with both passion and flavor.

Contact: 30 NY-25A Unit 2, Setauket-East Setauket, NY 11733
Phone: +1 631-675-0054